This site was really helpful for inspiration. I ended up using recipes from this site but made my own tags with a few tweaks to the recipes.
Set 1: Baked s'mores on the left and chai tea on the right (doubled the chai tea recipe).
Set 2: Sugar cookies, Baked s'mores, and Chocolate chip muffins. Added Ninjabread cookie cutters for their two boys, a ballerina cookie cutter for my goddaughter, and adorable printed muffin tins.